Forum › Forums › Miscellaneous › Broadcast, Internet, Media › Current BBC Recording Debacle
Tagged: BBC1-HD recording failures
- This topic has 57 replies, 15 voices, and was last updated 6 years, 7 months ago by
Anonymous.
-
AuthorPosts
-
March 6, 2019 at 10:14 pm #90236
Anonymous
InactiveYet another quirk this evening. I switched on our Youview box, went into the planner and noticed straight away that the box had recorded ‘Pointless’?
I don’t even watch the programme less still record it. This is getting beyond a joke. How when the box hasn’t been switched on all day can it suddenly take it upon itself to record random programmes?
Buck up BBC.
March 6, 2019 at 10:20 pm #90237grahamlthompson
ParticipantFaust – 1 minute ago »
Yet another quirk this evening. I switched on our Youview box, went into the planner and noticed straight away that the box had recorded ‘Pointless’?
I don’t even watch the programme less still record it. This is getting beyond a joke. How when the box hasn’t been switched on all day can it suddenly take it upon itself to record random programmes?
Buck up BBC.
Unless you actually tell the BBC what is happening there’s no chance they can know what is happening on every box out there ?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/complaints/complain-online/
They fixed my issue with the one programme and it now works fine.
March 6, 2019 at 10:44 pm #90238Anonymous
Inactivegrahamlthompson – 20 minutes ago »
Faust – 1 minute ago »
Yet another quirk this evening. I switched on our Youview box, went into the planner and noticed straight away that the box had recorded ‘Pointless’?
I don’t even watch the programme less still record it. This is getting beyond a joke. How when the box hasn’t been switched on all day can it suddenly take it upon itself to record random programmes?
Buck up BBC.
Unless you actually tell the BBC what is happening there’s no chance they can know what is happening on every box out there ?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/complaints/complain-online/
They fixed my issue with the one programme and it now works fine.
Already done this earlier today Graham, but thanks for the link. I can understand the logic of one CRID fits all on the Freeview platform as that relies on region and transmitter. However, the same does not apply to satellite PVRs and I’m still struggling to fathom why the BBC engineers thought this could ever be feasible.
March 7, 2019 at 8:42 am #90239grahamlthompson
ParticipantFaust – 9 hours ago »
grahamlthompson – 20 minutes ago »
Faust – 1 minute ago »
Yet another quirk this evening. I switched on our Youview box, went into the planner and noticed straight away that the box had recorded ‘Pointless’?
I don’t even watch the programme less still record it. This is getting beyond a joke. How when the box hasn’t been switched on all day can it suddenly take it upon itself to record random programmes?
Buck up BBC.
Unless you actually tell the BBC what is happening there’s no chance they can know what is happening on every box out there ?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/complaints/complain-online/
They fixed my issue with the one programme and it now works fine.
Already done this earlier today Graham, but thanks for the link. I can understand the logic of one CRID fits all on the Freeview platform as that relies on region and transmitter. However, the same does not apply to satellite PVRs and I’m still struggling to fathom why the BBC engineers thought this could ever be feasible.
According to Luke the CRID specs include the maintenance of a database that remembers which programme CRID’s are already recorded so this should prevent repeat recordings of the same content. It seems the G2 Humax boxes don’t have this capability hence the need for a seperate series CRID for each SD region and HD Nation variants. This will ensure it only records from the epg entry the reservation is set from.
Of course the AR timing also needs to be right as well.
March 7, 2019 at 2:35 pm #90240Anonymous
InactiveWell if what you say is true Graham (as related by Luke) then of late something is certainly going awry as my 1000s seems to be picking up recordings from various regions willy-nilly.
I can’t even begin to understand how the Youview box managed to record ‘Pointless’ last night either given I hadn’t touched it for days.
March 7, 2019 at 4:41 pm #90241Anonymous
InactiveJust noticed that Doctors did not record today, and was not set for tomorrow even though it is on series link.
But it was set to record next Monday!!
Had this problem a few weeks ago where it stopped recording for a whole week and just restarted the next week.
March 7, 2019 at 6:29 pm #90242grahamlthompson
ParticipantEgrosvenor – 1 hour ago »
Just noticed that Doctors did not record today, and was not set for tomorrow even though it is on series link.
But it was set to record next Monday!!
Had this problem a few weeks ago where it stopped recording for a whole week and just restarted the next week.
Also failed on FVP-5000T. One step forward and one backwards.
March 8, 2019 at 2:00 pm #90243grahamlthompson
ParticipantBargain Hunt BBC1-HD failed to record today on both Freeview and Freesat
March 8, 2019 at 6:48 pm #90244Anonymous
InactiveIt may, or may not, be associated with this, but during the afternoon I noticed that Eggheads on BBC1 HD was not showing tonight’s episode on the date list at the left of the playback list for the programme on my 5000T. (Not sure how to identify which list I mean – clearly!).
It was still showing on the EPG as programmed and also on the schedule, but I was not convinced.
So I programmed it again on BBC1 SD. I then found that it was showing on HD in the list where it had been missing, so I deleted the SD schedule.
I saw the recording start, so hopefully it completed.
Is this a BBC failing, or of the box? I have no idea!
March 10, 2019 at 4:53 pm #90245grahamlthompson
ParticipantEscape To The Country BBC1-HD is recording from both England and Wales.
Looks like I have to now delete Wales as well as Scotland. 😯
March 10, 2019 at 4:57 pm #90246Anonymous
Inactivegrahamlthompson – 2 minutes ago »
Escape To The Country BBC1-HD is recording from both England and Wales.
Looks like I have to now delete Wales as well as Scotland. 😯
Is this the start of Humexit?
March 10, 2019 at 10:25 pm #90247Anonymous
InactiveThe wife switched on our Freeview+ Panasonic PVR today to catch up with some of the programmes she has recorded over the last week.
Escape to the Country (series link) turned out to be a mixture of Shakespeare & Hathaway, Celebrity Impossible, plus the odd episode of Escape to the Country.
She then decided watch an episode of ‘Doctors’ (series link) only to find it was actually ‘final score’?
She wasn’t a happy bunny. What the hell are the BBC playing at?
All the programmes are set to record in SD BTW.
March 10, 2019 at 10:46 pm #90248Anonymous
InactiveTonight ‘Pointless Celebrities ‘failed to record both on freeveiw and freesat and strangely tried to record the program twice.
I discovered this when I was trying set up recordings for Comic Relief on Friday. Set up ok for freeveiw, but could not set up on Freesat because of ‘conflicts ‘ although I had no other programs set. Resorted to manual recordings. Emailed BBC again still got the usual check this and that.
I will try later in the week to set the recordings.
March 11, 2019 at 12:24 pm #90249grahamlthompson
ParticipantFixdit – 13 hours ago »
Tonight ‘Pointless Celebrities ‘failed to record both on freeveiw and freesat and strangely tried to record the program twice.
I discovered this when I was trying set up recordings for Comic Relief on Friday. Set up ok for freeveiw, but could not set up on Freesat because of ‘conflicts ‘ although I had no other programs set. Resorted to manual recordings. Emailed BBC again still got the usual check this and that.
I will try later in the week to set the recordings.
Thats because they were using the same CRIDS for BBC1-HD, England Wales and Scotland the clash was down to the box trying to set 3 recordings at the same time.
See post above, I think the penny has finally dropped.
March 11, 2019 at 1:52 pm #90250Anonymous
InactiveThat doesn’t explain the anomalies in my post 41 though Graham. The glitches are getting more bizarre by the week.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.